# Failure Report- Enterprise Products Operating, LLC 8/12/13

- **operation:** document
- **citation:** PHMSA FIR, Enterprise Products Operating, LLC, 2013-08-12
- **title:** Failure Report- Enterprise Products Operating, LLC 8/12/13
- **source type:** incident
- **agency:** Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration
- **status:** historical
- **official:** true
- **published on:** 2013-08-12
- **effective on:** 2013-08-12
- **summary:** Enterprise Products Operating, LLC; Hazardous Liquid; IL; failure 2013-08-12; apparent cause: Material Failure Pipe.
- **machine formats:** - **json:** https://regulus.evalyn.ai/document/phmsa-fir-failure-report-enterprise-products-operating-llc-81213.json
- **markdown:** https://regulus.evalyn.ai/document/phmsa-fir-failure-report-enterprise-products-operating-llc-81213.md
- **app url:** https://regulus.evalyn.ai/document/phmsa-fir-failure-report-enterprise-products-operating-llc-81213
- **source url:** https://www.phmsa.dot.gov/safety-reports/failure-report-enterprise-products-operating-llc-81213
**body:**

<<<PAGE 1>>>

DOT US Department of Transportation
PHMSA Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration
OPS Office of Pipeline Safety
Central Region
Principal Investigator Joe Elmer
Senior Accident Investigator Karen Butler
Region Director Linda Daugherty/ Allan Beshore
Date of Report 05/26/2015
Subject Failure Investigation Report – Enterprise Products Operating, LLC –
Material Failure
Operator, Location, & Consequences
Date of Failure 08/12/2013
Commodity Released Ethane/Propane Mix
City/County & State Erie / Whiteside, Illinois
OpID & Operator Name 31618 Enterprise Products Operating, LLC
Unit # & Unit Name 2313 (MAPCO) IOWA CITY
SMART Activity # 144352
Milepost / Location MP 16.2 / Morris Lateral (LID 624)
Type of Failure Rupture, Material Failure
Fatalities 0
Injuries 0
Description of area
impacted
Rural (corn field), non-HCA
Total Costs $515,000

<<<PAGE 2>>>

Failure Investigation Report – Enterprise Products Operating LLC – Material Failure
Failure Date 08/12/2013
Executive Summary1
On August 12, 2013, at approximately 11:14 p.m. CDT,
2 Enterprise Products Operating LLC’s (Enterprise)
10-inch nominal diameter Morris Lateral (LID 624) pipeline ruptured at M.P. 16.2, in Whiteside County,
near Erie, IL. The rupture resulted in the release of approximately 18,400 barrels of ethane/propane mix
into an agricultural field and was not located in a High Consequence Area (HCA). The product did ignite,
and an explosion associated with the rupture produced a crater in the ground approximately 36 feet
long and 22 feet wide.
A section of pipe approximately 33 feet in length was ejected from the ditch during the failure. The pipe
that was ejected from the ditch broke apart into 12 different pieces, which were recovered from the
corn field. No fatalities or injuries occurred as a result of the failure. A total of five roads were closed
and 32 homes evacuated as a result of the fire and explosion. The total cost of the failure, emergency
response, pipeline repair, and environmental cleanup is estimated at $515,000.
PHMSA worked with the operator throughout the week of August 12 to review and approve a restart
plan including a 20 percent reduction in maximum operating pressure, have metallurgical specialists on-
site before sections of the pipe failure were transferred, provide detailed emergency response timelines,
review metallurgical protocols, review previous close internal survey (CIS) and inline inspection (ILI)
data, and identify go forward integrity actions.
The fracture propagated both upstream and downstream from the origin of the failure. Metallurgical
analysis determined that the pipe failure was caused by a defect that formed in the longitudinal ERW
(HF) pipe seam. The defect was a combination of two flaws: an external surface breaking hook crack and
a crack that formed at the base of the hook crack and that grew to a critical size over time. Significant
corrosion by-products were also found present during the failure metallurgical analysis. Three failure
mechanisms were present and possible: 1) Environmental cracking such as SCC, 2) Pressure-cycle
induced fatigue crack growth, and 3) Corrosion-fatigue.
As a result of the failure and in concert with PHMSA discussion, Enterprise performed a hydrotest on the
Morris Lateral (LID 624), and an additional failure occurred during the hydrotest at MP 32.66. This failed
pipe also received a metallurgical analysis. The metallurgical analysis for the hydrotest failure identified
the failure cause as SCC (near-nuetral ph).
System Details
The Morris Lateral (LID 624) is also known as the Red Line and transports an ethane-propane mix from
Iowa City, IA, to the Lyondell petrochemical plants in Morris, IL, and Clinton, IA. An AuxsAble terminal
called Channahon is located on the east end of the Morris Lateral, also called the Red Line in Illinois. The
pipeline is a bi-directional line, but at the time of the failure the flow was from west to east. The pump
stations from west to east are located in Iowa and are as follows: Iowa City Terminal, Clinton, and
Willow. AuxAble is able to inject into the Morris Lateral at MP 107, therefore both AuxAble and
Enterprise are capable of delivering ethane-propane to Morris/Lyondell and Clinton/Lyondell locations.
At the failure location, the pipeline is constructed of API 5LX Grade X-52 line pipe manufactured in 1973
1 This Failure Investigation Report is based upon facts and information available to PHMSA at the time of issuance.
Any statements, conclusions, appendices, data summary, or findings stated herein are subject to revision and do
not constitute any final determination about the need for further investigation or enforcement action by any
government agency.
2 All times reflect Central Daylight Time (CDT) zone unless otherwise specifically noted.
Page 2 of 8

<<<PAGE 3>>>

Failure Investigation Report – Enterprise Products Operating LLC – Material Failure
Failure Date 08/12/2013
by American Steel Pipe Company. The pipeline is 10.750-inch O.D., 0.188-inch wall thickness, high
frequency ERW type pipe coated with cold applied tape. The pipeline is protected by an impressed
current type of cathodic protection system.
3 The nearest residence was located approximately 600
yards south of the rupture location. The nearest railroad line was located 2.75 miles north of the
rupture site.
The Morris Lateral’s maximum operating pressure (MOP) is 1,307 psig, which is equivalent to 72 percent
of the specified minimum yield strength of the pipe. The pipeline was hydrostatically tested in 1986 with
an 8-hour test and a minimum pressure of 1,741 psig, which was equivalent to 95.7 percent of the
specified minimum yield strength of the pipe. Documentation indicated that the highest historical
operating pressure for a portion of the pipeline from Clinton to MP 55.45 is 1,225 psig. Enterprise
reported that during the 1986 hydrostatic test, the line was tested in 11 segments, and 3 experienced
failures (two from mechanical damage and one from a pinhole in a weld). The metallurgical report
indicated that no hydrotest failures were recorded for this section of the pipeline that failed on August
12, 2013.
Events Leading up to the Failure
At approximately 6:09 p.m. on August 12, 2013, the controller started Pump No. 1 at the Willow pump
station in order to meet scheduled product delivery requirements. At 10:57 p.m., the discharge pressure
at the Willow pump station reached 1,254 psig, which was the highest pressure that was recorded at the
station just prior to the failure. This was also the highest pressure observed at this station in the 60 days
prior to the failure, and for a portion of the pipeline, exceeded the highest historical operating pressure
of 1,225 psig.
At 11:10 p.m., the discharge pressure at the Willow station dropped rapidly from 1,252 psig to 1,232
psig in a 15-second poll. At the same time, the Whiteside County Sheriff’s Department started to receive
911 calls of a fire north of I-80 and Erie Bridge. At 11:11 p.m., the pressure continued to drop at the
Willow station to 1,166 psig. The pressure was also dropping at the Van Orin block valve from 1,034 psig
to 1,011 psig. However, the pressure at Collins Lake Block valve was holding at 931 psig.
At 11:14 p.m., the Erie Fire Department was dispatched to the accident site.
At approximately 11:16 p.m., on August 12, 2013, Pump No. 1 at the Willow pump station shut down
because of low suction pressure and the SCADA system sensed a significant pressure drop on the
pipeline. The Houston Pipeline Control issued a start command to the Willow station Pump No. 2 at
11:17 p.m., however the Pump No. 2 failed to start due to low pressure on the pump suction. The
controller suspected a line break leak had occurred and requested that the operator at the Iowa City
pump station shut down the pumps at that location. At 11:23 p.m., Pump No. 1 at the Iowa City station
was shut down, and callouts to Enterprise personnel were started by 11:29 p.m.
Emergency Response
A resident who lives near the intersection of Albany Road and Stropes Road in Whiteside County, IL,
called the Erie Fire Protection District at 11:14 p.m. on August 12, 2013, to report a large fire in a corn
3 Tape coating systems may shield the pipe from cathodic protection currents, resulting in ineffective protection.
Page 3 of 8

<<<PAGE 4>>>

Failure Investigation Report – Enterprise Products Operating LLC – Material Failure
Failure Date 08/12/2013
field. Erie Fire Protection District personnel were dispatched to the Albany Road location and arrived at
the scene at 11:23 p.m. The Fire District personnel were able to determine that the fire was associated
with a pipeline that had ruptured. Product that was released from the pipeline ignited, and flames from
the fire reached heights up to 250 feet above the ground.
At 11:25 p.m., the controller closed MOV 9013 at Iowa City. By 11: 45 p.m., the Iowa City Terminal
operator had received a call from Cochin Pipeline’s control room stating that they had been made aware
of a pipeline fire in Illinois, and Enterprise technicians were being mobilized between Morris and Iowa
City. Alternate supply by AuxsAble to Morris/Lyondell was established by 11: 48 p.m. At 11:58 p.m. the
control room received a call from a farmer located near the pipeline who reported observing the fire.
The Fire District personnel determined that the pipeline was operated by Enterprise Products Pipeline
LLC and called the Enterprise Pipeline emergency number at approximately 12:00 a.m. on August 13,
2013. After the call from the Fire District, the Enterprise control room notified the Illinois Highway
Patrol of the situation. Enterprise Pipeline Company personnel and Erie Fire Protection District
personnel discussed the situation and together it was decided to set up a one-mile safety buffer around
the rupture site. Fire district personnel, with the assistance of other emergency responders, blocked
five roads within the safety buffer zone and evacuated all 32 residences that were located within the
safety buffer zone. Other emergency responders that assisted with activities at the accident location
included the Erie Police Department, the Fulton Police Department, the Prophetstown Police
Department, the Illinois State Police, the Whiteside Sherriff’s Department, and the Albany Fire
Department.
At 12:04 a.m. on August 13, 2013, the controller closed the MOVs at MP 55 and MP 116, which isolated
a 61-mile segment of the pipeline. On August 13, 2013, Enterprise Product Pipeline notified the
National Response Center (NRC) of the release at 12:17 a.m. (1:17 ET). The #3 MOV at Willow station
(MP 2) was closed by the controller at 12:17 a.m. and the manual valve at MP 107 was closed by
operations personnel at 12:35 a.m. Enterprise Pipeline Company personnel began to arrive at the
accident location at 1:03 a.m. Operations personnel closed the manual valve at MP 26 at 1:22 a.m. and
the manual valve at MP 27 at 1:32 a.m. A total of four Enterprise employees including the Regional
Manager were at the site by 2:17 a.m. The manual valve at MP 16 was closed at 2:35 a.m., isolating the
line segment between MP 16 and MP 26.
The occupants of all but two of the residences were allowed to return home by approximately 4:00 a.m.
At approximately 5:30 a.m. Enterprise Pipeline employees and the Erie District Fire Chief went to inspect
the immediate area of the rupture determined to be MP 16.2. The area was determined to be safe and
the fire was deemed under control. At that point the occupants of the final two residences were
allowed to return home, the roads were opened, and the Erie Fire district personnel were released from
the scene.
The Whiteside County ESDA and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 also responded to
the scene. COMED inspected the electric power lines in the area and no damage was reported.
Summary of Return-to-Service
On the evening of August 14, 2013, excavation activities commenced at the rupture site. The initial goal
of the excavation activities was to locate the girth weld immediately downstream of the rupture, located
Page 4 of 8

<<<PAGE 5>>>

Failure Investigation Report – Enterprise Products Operating LLC – Material Failure
Failure Date 08/12/2013
approximately 35 feet to the east of the crater. Enterprise submitted the repair plan to PHMSA on the
morning of August 15 and that plan was approved in the afternoon of August 15. Excavation of the
damaged section of the pipeline continued into the evening of August 15. At that point the length of the
exposed pipeline was approximately 250 feet. Girth welds at each end of the exposed pipe were located
and cuts were made at the girth welds and the exposed pipeline was removed from the ditch. The ends
of the pipe that remained in the ditch were prepared for welding and then examined nondestructively
to ensure that the pipe ends were free of any injurious defects.
While the excavation was proceeding, new replacement pipe was delivered to the repair site and was
welded into a 300-foot long segment with end caps. The pipe and end caps were welded together by
qualified welders who followed a qualified welding procedure. The welds were radiographed and met
the requirements of API 1104.
The replacement pipe segment was located above ground adjacent to the excavation. It was filled with
water and placed on hydrostatic at 2:45 p.m. on August 16, 2013. The replacement pipe segment was
tested to a pressure of 2,000 psig, which is equivalent to 110 percent SMYS. The test was complete at
7:28 p.m. on August 16. After the test was complete, the segment was dewatered, the end caps were
cut off, and the segment was cut into two segments to facilitate installation in the ditch.
The replacement pipe segments were placed in the ditch and aligned with the ends of the existing
pipeline. The three welds were completed early in the morning of August 17. The welds were
radiographed and met the requirements of API 1104.
After receiving PHMSA approval, Enterprise initiated the start-up plan at 7:00 a.m. on the morning of
August 17 by notifying the first responders in the area of the pipeline failure that the pipeline was being
re-started. After the notifications were made, the pipeline segment between the valve at MP 16 and
MP 26, which contained the repair segment, was purged with nitrogen. At 2:10 p.m. Enterprise began
filling that portion of the pipeline with product. At 6:00 p.m. the pressure in the line reached 860 psig
and that segment of the line was placed on a 2-hour hold test in accordance with the start-up plan.
During the hold test, aerial patrols were conducted and the line was monitored through the SCADA
system to ensure it was leak free. At 8:00 p.m. the control room took over operation of the pipeline and
was allowed to operate the line with an MOP of 960 psig at the Willow pump station. This represents a
20 percent reduction from the pressure at the time of the failure.
Investigation Details
PHMSA worked with the operator through teleconferences and data exchange throughout the week of
August 12 to review and approve a restart plan including a 20 percent reduction in maximum operating
pressure, have metallurgical specialists on-site before sections of the pipe failure were transferred,
provide detailed emergency response timelines, review metallurgical protocols, review previous CIS and
ILI data, and identify go forward integrity actions.
After the area was declared safe on the morning of August 13, Enterprise began initial site investigation
and located 11 small pieces of steel pipe that had been ejected from the ditch when the pipeline
ruptured. The pieces were numbered and cataloged by the location of each piece. A twelfth pipe
fragment was subsequently located.
On August 13, 2013, at approximately 1:36 p.m., a PHMSA Central Region Investigator arrived on scene.
The investigator photographed and diagrammed the scene and then interviewed Enterprise personnel
and first responders. On August 14, a metallurgist from Kiefner and Associates arrived at the failure site
Page 5 of 8

<<<PAGE 6>>>

Failure Investigation Report – Enterprise Products Operating LLC – Material Failure
Failure Date 08/12/2013
and began conducting an investigation into the cause of the failure, which included a visual examination
of the failure site and magnetic particle inspections on some of the failed pieces of pipe. Detailed
measurements of the longitudinal seam on each pipe fragment were made to ensure that all fragments
had been located. Once it was determined that all pieces had been found, each fragment was processed
and loaded onto a truck on August 16 for shipment to Kiefner’s laboratory in Columbus, OH. A chain of
custody document was prepared to ensure proper handling of the samples.
On August 15, 2013, Enterprise continued the site investigation and took a Ph reading in the crater (5.5).
A pipe to soil reading at the failure location and A/C reading at the same location were recorded as -
1.848 volts and 12.2 volts respectively.
While the failure area was not in an HCA, integrity data indicated that the pipeline had been smart
pigged several times:
A TDW Deformation tool run was performed on 4/10/2002 and a PII MFL tool run on 4/24/2002.
While deformations were present on the pipeline, no repairs occurred in the nearby area from
Valve AM76 to the small drainage ditch (drainage ditch was evident when reviewing the ROW in
the area of the failure).
A Tuboscope Deformation tool run on 7/14/2005 was performed to verify that the Tuboscope
UT tool run on 8/24/2005 could occur without damaging the tool. No deformation data was
analyzed. The ultrasonic tool run did not require any repairs in the area of the failure. However,
the pipeline contained 37 crack features: 6 crack-field, 30 crack-like, and 1 notch-like feature.
13 crack-like features were repaired with Type B sleeves and 14 crack-like features were
recoated. Two crack-fields features were sleeved, and four crack-field features were recoated.
Field observations did not indicate the presence of SCC, but three remaining crack-like features
and one remaining notch-like feature were not investigated.
A Magpie Combo MFL/DEF tool run occurred on 11/8/2006. The tool run did result in several
identifications but only one was found in the immediate area and was a topside dent with metal
loss. This feature was repaired with a Type B sleeve on 1/22/2007 and new coating was applied
but remained approximately 271 feet away from the failure site. Corrosion and deformation
anomalies do exist and indications appear to be increasing over time.
A Magpie Compo MFL/DEP tool run occurred again on 5/12/2010. While anomalies were found,
no repairs were made in the area of the failure (Valve AM76 to the drainage ditch). Corrosion
and deformation anomalies do exist and appear to be increasing (vendor threshold of detections
are more accurate but not all increases appear to be explained by this factor).
A close interval survey (CIS) was performed on a portion of the pipeline between MP 26 and MP 55.4 in
2007. While this did not cover the immediate area of the failure, findings from the CIS required that the
cathodic protection system be improved. An annual review of cathodic protection system performance
was completed in 2009 and did appear to have addressed concerns identified by the 2007 CIS. The
corrosion growth rate as it existed at the time of the failure determined that the earliest possible non-
repaired feature would fail by 5/8/2027. The pipeline has 39 reported casings. None are thought to be
shorted in the CIS area conducted in 2007.
A corrosion coupon is monitored upstream of Iowa City Terminal and has not shown a corrosion rate in
excess of 1 mil per year from 1997-2010.
Analysis for SCC was part of the integrity program prior to the failure, and a Phase II SCC study was
referenced. However in light of the failure, this program should benefit from being more aggressive and
a hydrotest was warranted.
Page 6 of 8

<<<PAGE 7>>>

Failure Investigation Report – Enterprise Products Operating LLC – Material Failure
Failure Date 08/12/2013
As part of the investigation, PHMSA requested that numerous documents be provided for review. The
documents provided by Enterprise included the CPDM Survey report (2011 – 2013) for the line segment
between Clinton and Morris pump stations, 2010 Inline Inspection (ILI) indications for the Morris Lateral,
the 2006 Close Interval Survey (CIS) Data between MP 14 and MP 19, the pressure/flow data for August
11, 12, and 13, Abnormal Operation Conditions (AOC) for 2013, coupon monitoring inspection records,
emergency incident logs, 2006 Magpie Combo MFL/DEF tool results, and the 2010 Magpie Combo
MFL/DEF tool results.
Findings and Contributing Factors
The Kiefner metallurgical examination determined that the cause of the failure was an original
manufacturing defect that grew in service until it reached critical size and failed at the operating
pressure. The original manufacturing defect was an external surface-breaking hook crack that measured
approximately 4.4 inches long and had a maximum depth of .062 inches, approximately 30 percent of
actual pipe wall thickness. A secondary defect formed at the base of the hook crack and grew over time
while the pipeline was in service. The overall length of the defect at the time of failure was 4.4 inches,
and the maximum depth of the combined defects was 0.161 inches, approximately 78 percent of actual
pipe wall thickness. Fractographic and metallographic examinations of the fracture surface were
completed. Thermal damage of the fracture surface prevented detailed microscopic examination of the
fracture surface, which could have helped to identify the actual growth mechanism of the secondary
defect. Metallurgical characteristics of the fracture surface were consistent with environmental cracking
(SCC) and with pressure-cycle induced fatigue, but were insufficient to conclusively identify the exact
growth mechanism. Corrosion-fatigue could also not be eliminated.
Pipe material properties were consistent with the requirements for the specified size and grade of pipe.
Enterprise Products Pipeline Company conducted a hydro-test of the Morris Lateral Pipeline for much of
the pipeline (from station # 0+0 to 6315+75). The hydro-test was planned to be conducted in four
sections in a 2 week span starting on July 7, 2014. On August 2, 2014, a hydro-test failure occurred at
MP 32.66 (station # 1724+53) at 1,425 psig with a target spike test pressure of 1,702 psig. The failed
pipe joint containing the failure measured 63.5 feet and was cut in the field to 20 feet-8 inches for
shipping to Keifner and Associates for metallurgical analysis.
The hydrotest failed pipe in the rupture area measured 46.5 inches long and was located approximately
27 inches downstream of a girth weld (labeled ESN 1724+47). The pipeline was constructed in 1973 of
10.75-inch outside diameter, 0.188-inch wall thickness, grade X52, high frequency electric-resistance
welded (HF-ERW) line pipe manufactured by American Steel Pipe and was coated with cold applied tape.
After the pipeline was repaired, the pipeline was successfully hydrotested to a spike test pressure of
1,702 psig for 30 minutes, followed by an 8-hour strength test at 1,653-psig on August 12, 2014.
The Kiefner metallurgical examination of the rupture determined that the cause of the hydro-test failure
was stress corrosion cracking (SCC) that developed in the ERW seam area. The SCC grew to a maximum
size of 3.3-inches long by .15-inches deep, approximately 80 percent of the pipe’s 0.188-inch nominal
wall thickness.
Enterprise will perform an Information Analysis to determine the method for reassessment of the
pipeline. Enterprise expects to complete the Information Analysis no later than the fall of 2016. The re-
assessment date for this pipeline will be determined through the Information Analysis process but will
not be longer than the 5-year interval, not to exceed 68 months.
Page 7 of 8

<<<PAGE 8>>>

Failure Investigation Report – Enterprise Products Operating LLC – Material Failure
Failure Date 08/12/2013
Based on the SCC threat, coating type, and other potential corrosion issues, PHMSA should elevate this
pipeline risk factor for inspection cycles/frequency.
Appendices
A Map and Photographs
B NRC Report
C Operator’s Accident Report
D Metallurgical Analysis
E Hydrostatic Test Results
Page 8 of 8

<<<PAGE 9>>>

Appendix A Maps and Photographs
Map of accident location
) Pipoline and Heard
I(b) (7)(F)
erial Safaty Administrat
OPID31618 Enterprise Products Operating, LLC - Erie, IL Accident
PHIS CENTRAL REGION
25 25
View of Accident Site Looking South
(Photograph Taken by Enterprise Products Operating, LLC
Page 1 of 7

<<<PAGE 10>>>

Appendix A Maps and Photographs
Morris Lateral Map (Red Line).
Page 2 of 7

<<<PAGE 11>>>

Appendix A Maps and Photographs
View Rupture Area Looking Southeast
(Photograph Taken by Enterprise Products Operating, LLC)
View of ROW Looking Northwest
Page 3 of 7

<<<PAGE 12>>>

Appendix A Maps and Photographs
View of Rupture Area Looking Southeast
Exterior View of Piece # 2 (Containing Failure Origin)
Page 4 of 7

<<<PAGE 13>>>

Appendix A Maps and Photographs
Interior View of Piece # 2 (Containing Failure Origin)
View of All Fragments Being Processed
Page 5 of 7

<<<PAGE 14>>>

Appendix A Maps and Photographs
View of All Fragments Processed For Shipping
View of Pressure Gauge During Hydrostatic Test of Replacement Pipe
Page 6 of 7

<<<PAGE 15>>>

Appendix A Maps and Photographs
View of Crater with Replacement Pipe
View of Repaired Pipe Looking Northwest
Page 7 of 7

<<<PAGE 16>>>

Appendix B - NRC Report
NATIONAL RESPONSE CENTER 1-800-424-8802
***GOVERNMENT USE ONLY***GOVERNMENT USE ONLY***
Information released to a third party shall comply with any
applicable federal and/or state Freedom of Information and Privacy Laws
Incident Report # 1056922
INCIDENT DESCRIPTION
*Report taken by: CIV ANTONAY GREER at 01:17 on 13-AUG-13
Incident Type: PIPELINE
Incident Cause: EQUIPMENT FAILURE
Affected Area:
Incident was discovered on 12-AUG-13 at 23:20 local incident time.
Affected Medium: AIR / ATMOSPHERE
REPORTING PARTY
Name:
GREG BENDER
Organization: ENTERPRISE PRODUCT PIPELINE
Address:
9420 WEST SAM HOUSTON PKWY NORTH
HOUSTON, TX 77064
PRIMARY Phone: (281)8872640
Type of Organization: PRIVATE ENTERPRISE
Page 1 of 6

<<<PAGE 17>>>

Appendix B - NRC Report
_______________________________________________________________________
SUSPECTED RESPONSIBLE PARTY
Name: GREG BENDER
Organization: ENTERPRISE PRODUCT PIPELINE
Address: 9420 WEST SAM HOUSTON PKWY NORTH
HOUSTON, TX 77064
PRIMARY Phone: (281)8872640
________________________________________________________________________
INCIDENT LOCATION
County: WHITESIDE
City: ERIE State: IL
ERIE AND ALBANY RD.
_______________________________________________________________________
RELEASED MATERIAL(S)
CHRIS Code: NCC Official Material Name: NO CHRIS CODE
Also Known As: ETHANE PROPANE
Qty Released: 32818 BARREL(S)
________________________________________________________________________
DESCRIPTION OF INCIDENT
THE CALLER REPORTED THAT ETHANE PROPANE IS RELEASING FROM A 10"
STEEL PIPELINE DUE TO A LINE RUPTURE. AS A RESULT OF THE RELEASE A
FIRE IGNITED, WITH THE POSSIBILITY TO RELEASE UP TO 32,818 BARRELS
OF MATERIAL (THIS NUMBER HAS NOT BEEN CONFIRMED, HOWEVER IS A
SPECULATED AMOUNT FROM BLOCK VALVE TO BLOCK VALVE). THE REPORTING
SOURCE WILL CONTACT THE NRC WITH AN UPDATED QUANTITY.
Page 2 of 6

<<<PAGE 18>>>

Appendix B - NRC Report
________________________________________________________________________
SENSITIVE INFORMATION
________________________________________________________________________
INCIDENT DETAILS
Pipeline Type: DISTRIBUTION
DOT Regulated: YES
Pipeline Above/Below Ground: BELOW
Exposed or Under Water: NO
Pipeline Covered: UNKNOWN
______________________________________________________________________
IMPACT
Fire Involved: YES Fire Extinguished: NO
INJURIES: NO Hospitalized: Empl/Crew: Passenger:
FATALITIES: NO Empl/Crew: Passenger: Occupant:
EVACUATIONS:NO Who Evacuated: Radius/Area:
Damages: NO
Hours Direction of
Closure Type Description of Closure Closed Closure
N
Air:
N Major
Road: Artery:N
N
Page 3 of 6

<<<PAGE 19>>>

Appendix B - NRC Report
Waterway:
N
Track:
Environmental Impact: UNKNOWN
Media Interest: NONE Community Impact due to Material:
______________________________________________________________________
REMEDIAL ACTIONS
THAT SECTION OF THE PIPE HAS BEEN ISOLATED
Release Secured: NO
Release Rate:
Estimated Release Duration:
______________________________________________________________________
WEATHER
Weather: UNKNOWN, ºF
______________________________________________________________________
ADDITIONAL AGENCIES NOTIFIED
Federal:
State/Local: STATE POLICE
State/Local On Scene:
State Agency Number:
_______________________________________________________________________
NOTIFICATIONS BY NRC
ATLANTIC STRIKE TEAM (MAIN OFFICE)
13-AUG-13 01:33 (609)7240008
Page 4 of 6

<<<PAGE 20>>>

Appendix B - NRC Report
CG INVESTIGATIVE SVC CHICAGO (CGIS RAO CHICAGO)
13-AUG-13 01:33 (630)9862160
CGIS RAO ST. LOUIS (COMMAND CENTER)
13-AUG-13 01:33 (314)2692420
DHS PROTECTIVE SECURITY ADVISOR (PSA DESK)
13-AUG-13 01:33 (703)2355724
DOT CRISIS MANAGEMENT CENTER (MAIN OFFICE)
13-AUG-13 01:33 (202)3661863
EPA CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION DIVISION (CID REGION V)
13-AUG-13 01:33 (312)8869872
U.S. EPA V (MAIN OFFICE)
(312)3532318
USCG NATIONAL COMMAND CENTER (MAIN OFFICE)
(202)3722100
IA U.S. ATTORNEY'S OFFICE (INTELLIGENCE OFFICER)
13-AUG-13 01:33 (515)4739345
IL U.S. ATTORNEY'S OFFICE CENTRAL (MAIN OFFICE)
13-AUG-13 01:33 (217)4924402
IL DNR (MAIN OFFICE)
13-AUG-13 01:33 (217)5577817
IL STATE EMERG AGCY (MAIN OFFICE)
13-AUG-13 01:33 (217)7827860
NATIONAL INFRASTRUCTURE COORD CTR (MAIN OFFICE)
13-AUG-13 01:33 (202)2829201
NOAA RPTS FOR IL (MAIN OFFICE)
13-AUG-13 01:33 (206)5264911
NATIONAL RESPONSE CENTER HQ (MAIN OFFICE)
(202)2671136
Page 5 of 6

<<<PAGE 21>>>

Appendix B - NRC Report
NATIONAL RESPONSE CENTER HQ (AUTOMATIC REPORTS)
13-AUG-13 01:33 (202)2671136
NRC SENIOR WATCH OFFICER (MAIN OFFICE)
(202)2672100
NTSB PIPELINE (MAIN OFFICE)
13-AUG-13 01:33 (202)3146293
PIPELINE & HAZMAT SAFETY ADMIN (OFFICE OF PIPELINE SAFETY (AUTO))
13-AUG-13 01:33 (202)3660568
MSD QUAD CITIES (MAIN OFFICE)
13-AUG-13 01:33 (309)7820627
SECTOR UPPER MISSISSIPPI RIVER (COMMAND CENTER)
(314)2692332
IA DEPT NAT RES ATTN: DUTY OFFICER (MAIN OFFICE)
13-AUG-13 01:33 (515)2818694
IL EPA ERT (MAIN OFFICE)
13-AUG-13 01:33 (217)7823637
DOI/OEPC DENVER (MAIN OFFICE)
13-AUG-13 01:33 (303)4452500
USCG DISTRICT 8 (MAIN OFFICE)
13-AUG-13 01:33 (504)5896225
_______________________________________________________________________
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
THE CALLER HAD VERY LITTLE INFORMATION AT THE TIME OF THE REPORT.
______________________________________________________________________
*** END INCIDENT REPORT #1056922 ***
Report any problems by calling 1-800-424-8802
PLEASE VISIT OUR WEB SITE AT http://www.nrc.uscg.mil
Page 6 of 6

<<<PAGE 22>>>

Appendix C - Operator's Accident Report
NOTICE: This report is required by 49 CFR Part 195. Failure to report can result in a civil penalty not to
exceed $100,000 for each violation for each day that such violation persists except hat the maximum civil
penalty shall not exceed $1,000,000 as provided in 49 USC 60122.
OMB NO: 2137-0047
EXPIRATION DATE: 07/31/2015
Original Report
Date: 09/10/2013
U.S Department of Transportation
Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration
No. 20130307 - 20452
--------------------------
(DOT Use Only)
ACCIDENT REPORT - HAZARDOUS LIQUID
PIPELINE SYSTEMS
A federal agency may not conduct or sponsor, and a person is not required to respond to, nor shall a person be subject to a penalty for failure to comply
with a collection of information subject to the requirements of the Paperwork Reduction Act unless that collection of information displays a current valid
OMB Control Number. The OMB Control Number for this information collection is 2137-0047. All responses to the collection of information are mandatory.
Send comments regarding this burden or any other aspect of his collection of information, including suggestions for reducing the burden to: Information
Collection Clearance Officer, PHMSA, Office of Pipeline Safety (PHP-30) 1200 New Jersey Avenue, SE, Washington, D.C. 20590.
INSTRUCTIONS
Important: Please read the separate instructions for completing this form before you begin. They clarify the information requested and provide specific
examples. If you do not have a copy of the instructions, you can obtain one from the PHMSA Pipeline Safety Community Web Page at
http://www.phmsa.dot.gov/pipeline/library/forms.
PART A - KEY REPORT INFORMATION
Report Type: (select all that apply) Original: Supplemental: Final:
Yes Yes
Last Revision Date: 05/18/2015
1. Operator's OPS-issued Operator Identification Number (OPID): 31618
2. Name of Operator ENTERPRISE PRODUCTS OPERATING LLC
3. Address of Operator:
3a. Street Address 1100 Louisiana Street
3b. City HOUSTON
3c. State Texas
3d. Zip Code 77002
4. Local time (24-hr clock) and date of the Accident: 08/12/2013 23:10
5. Location of Accident:
Latitude: 41.697667
Longitude: -90.098627
6. National Response Center Report Number (if applicable): 1056922
7. Local time (24-hr clock) and date of initial telephonic report to the
National Response Center (if applicable): 08/13/2013 00:17
8. Commodity released: (select only one, based on predominant
volume released)
HVL or Other Flammable or Toxic Fluid which is a Gas at
Ambient Conditions
- Specify Commodity Subtype: Other HVL
- If "Other" Subtype, Descr be: Ethane/Propane Mix
- If Biofuel/Alternative Fuel and Commodity Subtype is
Ethanol Blend, then % Ethanol Blend:
- If Biofuel/Alternative Fuel and Commodity Subtype is
Biodiesel, then Biodiesel Blend e.g. B2, B20, B100
9. Estimated volume of commodity released unintentionally (Barrels): 18,400.00
10. Estimated volume of intentional and/or controlled release/blowdown
(Barrels):
11. Estimated volume of commodity recovered (Barrels):
12. Were there fatalities? No
- If Yes, specify the number in each category:
12a. Operator employees
12b. Contractor employees working for the Operator
12c. Non-Operator emergency responders
12d. Workers working on the right-of-way, but NOT
associated with this Operator
12e. General public
12f. Total fatalities (sum of above)
13. Were there injuries requiring inpatient hospitalization? No
- If Yes, specify the number in each category:
13a. Operator employees
13b. Contractor employees working for the Operator
13c. Non-Operator emergency responders
13d. Workers working on the right-of-way, but NOT
associated with this Operator
13e. General public
Form PHMSA F 7000.1
Page 1 of 14

<<<PAGE 23>>>

Appendix C - Operator's Accident Report
13f. Total injuries (sum of above)
14. Was the pipeline/facility shut down due to the Accident? Yes
- If No, Explain:
- If Yes, complete Questions 14a and 14b: (use local time, 24-hr clock)
14a. Local time and date of shutdown: 08/12/2013 23:16
14b. Local time pipeline/facility restarted: 08/17/2013 20:33
- Still shut down? (* Supplemental Report Required)
15. Did the commodity ignite? Yes
16. Did the commodity explode? Yes
17. Number of general public evacuated: 32
18. Time sequence (use local time, 24-hour clock):
18a. Local time Operator identified Accident - effective 7- 2014
changed to "Local time Operator identified failure": 08/12/2013 23:16
18b. Local time Operator resources arrived on site: 08/13/2013 01:03
PART B - ADDITIONAL LOCATION INFORMATION
1. Was the origin of the Accident onshore? Yes
If Yes, Complete Questions (2-12)
If No, Complete Questions (13-15)
- If Onshore:
2. State: Illinois
3. Zip Code: 61250
4. City Erie
5. County or Parish Whiteside
6. Operator-designated location: Milepost/Valve Station
Specify: Milepost 16.2
7. Pipeline/Facility name: MAPL East Leg - Morris Lateral
8. Segment name/ID: LID 624
9. Was Accident on Federal land, other than the Outer Continental Shelf
(OCS)? No
10. Location of Accident: Pipeline Right-of-way
11. Area of Accident (as found): Underground
Specify: Under soil
- If Other, Describe:
Depth-of-Cover (in): 48
12. Did Accident occur in a crossing? No
- If Yes, specify type below:
- If Bridge crossing –
Cased/ Uncased:
- If Railroad crossing –
Cased/ Uncased/ Bored/drilled
- If Road crossing –
Cased/ Uncased/ Bored/drilled
- If Water crossing –
Cased/ Uncased
- Name of body of water, if commonly known:
- Approx. water depth (ft) at the point of the Accident:
- Select:
- If Offshore:
13. Approximate water depth (ft) at the point of the Accident:
14. Origin of Accident:
- In State waters - Specify:
- State:
- Area:
- Block/Tract #:
- Nearest County/Parish:
- On the Outer Continental Shelf (OCS) - Specify:
- Area:
- Block #:
15. Area of Accident:
PART C - ADDITIONAL FACILITY INFORMATION
1. Is the pipeline or facility: Interstate
2. Part of system involved in Accident: Onshore Pipeline, Including Valve Sites
- If Onshore Breakout Tank or Storage Vessel, Including Attached
Appurtenances, specify:
3. Item involved in Accident: Pipe
- If Pipe, specify: Pipe Seam
3a. Nominal diameter of pipe (in): 10
Form PHMSA F 7000.1
Page 2 of 14

<<<PAGE 24>>>

Appendix C - Operator's Accident Report
3b. Wall thickness (in): .188
3c. SMYS (Specified Minimum Yield Strength) of pipe (psi): 52,000
3d. Pipe specification: API 5L
3e. Pipe Seam , specify: Longitudinal ERW - High Frequency
- If Other, Describe:
3f. Pipe manufacturer: American Steel
3g. Year of manufacture: 1973
3h. Pipeline coating type at point of Accident, specify: Cold Applied Tape
- If Other, Describe:
- If Weld, including heat-affected zone, specify. If Pipe Girth Weld,
3a through 3h above are required:
- If Other, Describe:
- If Valve, specify:
- If Mainline, specify:
- If Other, Describe:
3i. Manufactured by:
3j. Year of manufacture:
- If Tank/Vessel, specify:
- If Other - Describe:
- If Other, descr be:
4. Year item involved in Accident was installed: 1973
5. Material involved in Accident: Carbon Steel
- If Material other than Carbon Steel, specify:
6. Type of Accident Involved: Rupture
- If Mechanical Puncture – Specify Approx. size:
in. (axial) by
in. (circumferential)
- If Leak - Select Type:
- If Other, Describe:
- If Rupture - Select Orientation: Longitudinal
- If Other, Describe:
Approx. size: in. (widest opening) by 10
in. (length circumferentially or axially) 393
- If Other – Describe:
PART D - ADDITIONAL CONSEQUENCE INFORMATION
1. Wildlife impact: No
1a. If Yes, specify all that apply:
- Fish/aquatic
- Birds
- Terrestrial
2. Soil contamination: Yes
3. Long term impact assessment performed or planned: Yes
4. Anticipated remediation: Yes
4a. If Yes, specify all that apply:
- Surface water
- Groundwater Yes
- Soil Yes
- Vegetation
- Wildlife
5. Water contamination: Yes
5a. If Yes, specify all that apply:
- Ocean/Seawater
- Surface
- Groundwater Yes
- Drinking water: (Select one or both)
- Private Well
- Public Water Intake
5b. Estimated amount released in or reaching water (Barrels): .00
5c. Name of body of water, if commonly known: Perched water bearing zone.
6. At the location of this Accident, had the pipeline segment or facility
been identified as one that "could affect" a High Consequence Area
(HCA) as determined in the Operator's Integrity Management Program?
No
7. Did the released commodity reach or occur in one or more High
Consequence Area (HCA)? No
7a. If Yes, specify HCA type(s): (Select all that apply)
- Commercially Navigable Waterway:
Was this HCA identified in the "could affect"
determination for this Accident site in the Operator's
Form PHMSA F 7000.1
Page 3 of 14

<<<PAGE 25>>>

Appendix C - Operator's Accident Report
Integrity Management Program?
- High Population Area:
Was this HCA i
- **truncated:** true
- **body characters:** 68400
