# NK CO., LTD — Hazardous Materials Safety Interpretation - **operation:** document - **citation:** 12-0202 - **title:** NK CO., LTD — Hazardous Materials Safety Interpretation - **source type:** guidance - **agency:** Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration - **status:** guidance - **official:** true - **published on:** 2012-10-18 - **effective on:** Not available - **summary:** 12-0202 response to NK CO., LTD concerning 178.37. - **machine formats:** - **json:** https://regulus.evalyn.ai/document/phmsa-interpretation-12-0202.json - **markdown:** https://regulus.evalyn.ai/document/phmsa-interpretation-12-0202.md - **app url:** https://regulus.evalyn.ai/document/phmsa-interpretation-12-0202 - **source url:** https://www.phmsa.dot.gov/sites/phmsa.dot.gov/files/legacy/interpretations/Interpretations/2012/120202.pdf **body:** <<>> U.S. Department of Transportation Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety · · Administration 1200 New Jersey Avenue SE Washington. DC 20590 OCT 1 8 2012 Mr. Hyun-Joon Ji Assistant Manager Quality Inspection Team NKCO.,LTD 497, Sinpyeong-dong, Saha-gu, Busan 604-030, Korea Ref. No.: 12-0202 Dear Mr. Ji: This is in response to your September 10,2012 email concerning the requirements for cylinders in accordance with the Hazardous Materials Regulations (HMR; 49 CFR Parts 171-180). Specifically you request confirmation of your understanding of the appropriate lot size for conducting the physical tests on DOT 3AA and DOT 3AAX cylinders. As provided in§ 178.37(k), a physical test must be conducted to determine the yield strength, tensile strength, elongation and reduction of area of material. The test is required on two specimens cut from one cylinder taken at random out of each lot of 200 or less. Alternatively, for lots of thirty or less, the physical tests are authorized to be made on a ring at least 8 inches (20 em) long cut from one cylinder and subjected to the same heat treatment as the finished cylinder(s). I hope this information is helpful. If you have further questions, please do not hesitate to contact this oftice. Delmer Billings Senior Regulatory Advisor Standards and Rulemaking Division <<>> 1 eary Drakeford, Carolyn (PHMSA) 3178.34 From: Sent: Betts, Charles (PHMSA) Subject: To: Monday, September 10, 2012 10:32 AM Drakeford, Carolyn (PHMSA) Cylinders FW: [FW]:RE: A inquire related to DOT Audit at NK-Korea 12-0202 Importance: High Carolyn - Please log and assigned to Kevin for response. Thanks, Charles From: hjji@nkcf.com [mailto:hjji@nkcf.com] Sent: Monday, September 10, 2012 8:19 AM To: Betts, Charles (PHMSA) Cc: Chaney, Wayne (PHMSA); Lynch, Tom (PHMSA) Subject: [FW]: RE: A inquire related to DOT Audit at NK-Korea Dear Mr. Charles Betts, This is a personnel (Mr. Hyun-Joon Ji) in charge of Q.C of NK CO in South Korea. Recently our company has had a fitness inspection for approvals of DOT specification and UN ISO cylinder. During the fitness inspection we have inquired of DOT investigators about a lot size in the heat treatment process and we could get a reply from them that a lot size could be maximum 200 as long as it is subject to the same heat. Also one test ring could be applied to a lot of 30 or less as long as it represents the same heat. Therefore we would like to get your official confirmation to clarify a lot size according to the e-mail below. Please kindly let us know your reply about our question. Best Regards, ******** ******* Hyun-Joon Ji, Assistant Manager (7/51 ECH21) NA CO. LTD / (70301 Direct : +82 (0)51 899 0112 / Fax. +82 (0)51 832 0135 Mobile: +82 (0) 10 8382 3533 E-mail : hiji@nkcf.com ******* • Original Message From : To : 1 <<>> CC : Sent : 2012-09-08 1:53:04 AM Subject : RE: A inquire related to DOT Audit at NK-Korea Mr. Hyun-Joon Ji, You are correct in the email below, you can have a lot size of 200 or less, also in talking with one of our PHMSA engineers one ring could be used for a lot as long as it represents the same heat for the lot of 30 or less. As an senior enforcement investigator my personal interpretation cannot be used as an official interpretation there for it is best that you request an official interpretation from PHMSA Standards. The person to contact is Mr. Charles Betts at email Charles.betts@dot.gov. you may forward my email as well. I have talked with Mr. Glenn Foster, Chief, Regulatory Review and Reinvention Standards, and he has been made aware of your email to me. Best regards Wayne Wayne E. Chaney Sr. Hazrdardous Material Investigator/ Cylinder Program Manager East Building, PHH -40 1200 New Jersey Ave, SE Washington, DC 20590-0001 202 834-3568 Fax: 404 393-9552 wayne.chaney@dot.gov From: hjji@nkd.com [mailto:hjji@nkd.coml Sent: Wednesday, September 05, 2012 5:39AM To: Chaney, Wayne (PHMSA) Subject: A inquire related to DOT Audit at NK-Korea Dear Mr. Chaney, We always thank for your help. 2 <<>> Could you please let us get your reply to below e-mail? We are sorry to bother you with this question again. This is NK's important concerns and we very appreciate if you reply to us about it. Best Regards, ***************************************************** Hyun-Joon Ji, Assistant Manager (118 2 CH21) NA COLD LD/(7)30 Direct : +82 (0)51 899 0112 / Fax. +82 (0)51 832 0135 Mobile: +82 (0)10 8382 3533 E-mail : hiji@nkcf.com ****************************** ************** • Original Message-- From : CN=T|#=/OU=10928/O=nke To : Wayne.Chaney@dot.gov CC : Sent : 2012-09-03 5:08:21 PM Subject : A inquire related to DOT Audit at NK-Korea Dear Mr. Chaney, We are looking forward to getting a good result for the fitness inspection. By the way, now we plan to revise the "Lot control procedure" to reflect a lot size (maximum 200) of heat treatment based on the point that you advised during NK's question time at the end of the audit. At first NK have defined a lot size as two cylinders having the same heat number and the same heat treatment condition. Therefore NK have attahced a test ring every two cylinders and then would conduct the physical tests with the test ring. However, I believe that this is very inefficient LOT composition considering the DOT regulation § 178.37 (The physical tests are authorized to conducted on a test ring for lot of 30 maximum). So prior to a revision of our procedure I would like to get your agreement with settling a lot size by maximum 30 cylinders as long as cylinders have the same heat number and heat treatment condition in the heat treatment process. Please kindly let us get your confirmation if you don't have any comments. Best Regards, 3 <<>> ******* Hyun Joon Ji, Assistant Manager (16 82 12) Direct : +82 (0)51 899 0112 / Fax. +82 (0)51 832 0135 Mobile: +82 (0)10 8382 3533 E-mail : hiji@nkcf.com *************************** ******** • Original Message-- From : To : CC : Sent: 2012-08-27 9:49:35 PM Subject : RE: NK Corrective Action related to DOT Audit at NK-Korea Thank you for the corrective actions as submitted, once the lIA testing is complete I will inform you of the results of your fitness inspection. R/ Wayne Wayne E. Chaney Sr. Hazrdardous Material Investigator/ Cylinder Program Manager East Building, PHH-40 1200 New Jersey Ave, SE Washington, DC 20590-0001 202 834-3568 Fax: 404 393-9552 <<>> wayne. chaney@dot. gov From: hjji@nkd.com [mailto:hjji@nkd.coml Sent: Sunday, August 26, 2012 10:31 PM To: Chaney, Wayne (PHMSA) Cc: Lynch, Tom (PHMSA) Subject: NK Corrective Action related to DOT Audit at NK-Korea Dear Mr.Chaney, Please review NK's corrective action for your findings during the audit for NK in Korea. Finding #1) Application for 3AA/3AAX/3T does not show hold points for I lA Witnessing. Corrective Action) Flow chart for DOT3AA/3AAX/3T has been revised in order to reflect DOT comment by adding Independent Inspector's Inspection point (Verify, Witness).(See Attachment #1 Finding #2) Failure to calculate proper wall thickness. Corrective Action) NK has measured the actual wall thickness for raw material at the time of receiveing inspection and recorded the actual wall thickness on receiving inspection check sheet. As per your comment NK will calcuate the wall stress by measuring actual wall thickness for each LOT, but not simply use the wall thickness mentioned in the Drawing.{See Attachment #2) Finding #3) Chemical analyses should be accomplish upon arrival of material. Corrective Action) NK modified the Flow Chart for Manufacturing and Inspection and Traveller Sheet according to DOT's comment. 5 <<>> So chemical Analyses will be conducted based on each heat of material at the stage of receiving inspection of the material. (See Attachment #1) Finding #4) Ensure hydrostatic retesting is performed using equipment proven to be within 1% accuracy. Corrective Action) NK has found the cause of failure to meet 1% accuracy requirement of the equipment and then repaired it. (See Attachment #3) Finding #5) Failure to hold hydrostatic test pressure for at least 30 sec on longer to reach full expansion. Corrective Action) NK has holded the hydrostatic test pressure for at least 30 sec for only manufactured cylinders not a calibration cylinder. However NK has taken action to apply holding time for at least 30 sec for the each pressure level of the calibration cylinder as weii.(See Attachment #4) Finding #6) For Jumbo Hydrostatic Retesting & Testing records missing calibration cylinder serial number used to calibration system. Corrective Action) NK has recorded the calibration cylinder number on the test records and to prevent any repetiton, the tester and Q.C inspector have been trained for the requirement. (See Attachment #4,6) Finding #7) Records missing elastic & permanent expansion on calibration sheets Corrective Action) NK has trained the test operators to record elastic & permanent expansion on the test record. (See Attachment #6) Finding #8) Test records of Jumbo & Medium must have legible identification of the test operator. Corrective Action) NK Q.M has performed necessary training to the Inspector and Tester to legible identification on the Record/Report by their registered identification such as clearly spelled out name 6 <<>> and signature registered. (See Attachment #5, 6) Finding #9) Test records must record actual test pressure applied to each cylinder. Corrective Action) NK has trained the test operators to record the actual test pressure on the test record when hydrostatic test is conducted. (See Attachment #6) Finding #10) Retest records missing actual dimensions of cylinder. Corrective Action) NK has trained the test operators to record the actual dimensions on the test record. (See Attachment #6) Finding #11) Observed DOT-SP 14003 & DOT E10945 composit cylinders being retested at facility under Korean Standards, cylinder should meet All DOT Requirement under the special permits. Corrective Action) NK has conducted the retest of composit cylinders according to the customer request that is required to NK follow only Korean Standard not DOT regulation. We NK Q.M Div. have well trained about those requirement and will implement above mentioned element and corrective action immediately to the production and Inspection of DOT Cylinder. If you have any question, please let us know. Attachment 1: Manufacturing Process Flow Chart & Traveller Sheet -4 pages 2: Receiving Inspection Report - 1 page 3: Verification for proving 1% Accuracy of the Hydro Test Machine. - 9 pages. 4: High and Low seting -Calibration of test system -1 page 5: Log of Signature Registered for Inspection and Test Personnel - 1 page 6: Training Record for DOT comments. - 1 page ***************************************************** Direct: +82 (0)51 899 0112 / Fax. +82 (0)51 832 0135 Mobile: +82 (0)10 8382 3533 7 <<>> E-mail : hjji@nkcf.com ********************************* ********** 8 - **truncated:** false - **body characters:** 11157