NTSB Safety Recommendation Letter P-00-019

Page 1Official PDFNational Transportation Safety Board Washington, D.C. 20594 Safety Recommendation Date: September 27, 2000 In reply refer to: P-00-19 Mr. Douglas H. Yeager Chief Executive Officer Laclede Gas Company 720 Olive Street St. Louis, Missouri 63101 The National Transportation Safety Board is an independent Federal agency charged by Congress with investigating transportation accidents, determining their probable cause, and making recommendations to prevent similar accidents from occurring. We are providing the following information to urge your organization to take action on the safety recommendation in this letter. The Safety Board is vitally interested in this recommendation because it is designed to prevent accidents and save lives. The recommendation addresses the effectiveness of safety measures provided for the permanently moored vessel President Casino on the Admiral (Admiral) and the adequacy of public safety for permanently moored vessels. The recommendation is derived from the Safety Board’s investigation of the April 4, 1998, marine accident concerning the ramming of the Eads Bridge by barges in tow of the M/V Anne Holly with subsequent ramming and near breakaway of the Admiral in St. Louis Harbor, Missouri,1 and is consistent with the evidence we found and the analysis we performed. As a result of this investigation, the Safety Board has issued 30 safety recommendations, 1 of which is addressed to the Laclede Gas Company. Information supporting the recommendation is discussed below. The Safety Board would appreciate a response from you within 90 days addressing the actions you have taken or intend to take to implement our recommendation. About 1950 on April 4, 1998, a tow of the M/V Anne Holly, comprising 12 loaded and 2 empty barges, which was traveling northbound on the Mississippi River through the St. Louis Harbor, struck the Missouri-side pier of the center span of the Eads Bridge. Eight barges broke away from the tow and drifted back through the Missouri span. Three of these barges drifted toward the Admiral, a permanently moored gaming vessel below the bridge on the Missouri side of the river. The drifting barges struck the moored Admiral, causing 8 of its 10 mooring lines to break. The Admiral then rotated clockwise downriver, away from the Missouri riverbank. The 1 For additional information, see forthcoming Marine Accident Report NTSB/MAR-00/01: Ramming of the Eads Bridge by Barges in Tow of the M/V Anne Holly with Subsequent Ramming and Near Breakaway of the President Casino on the Admiral, St. Louis Harbor, Missouri, April 4, 1998, (Washington, DC: National Transportation Safety Board, 2000). 7009B#

Page 22 captain of the Anne Holly disengaged his vessel from the six remaining barges in the tow and placed the Anne Holly’s bow against the Admiral’s bow to hold it against the bank. About the time the Anne Holly began pushing against the Admiral, the Admiral’s next-to-last mooring line parted. The Anne Holly and the single mooring wire that remained attached to the Admiral’s stern anchor held the Admiral near the Missouri bank. No deaths resulted from the accident; 50 people were examined for minor injuries. Of those examined, 16 were sent to local hospitals for further treatment. Damages were estimated at $11 million. The National Transportation Safety Board determined that the probable cause of the ramming of the Eads Bridge in St. Louis Harbor by barges in tow of the Anne Holly and the subsequent breakup of the tow was the poor decision-making of the captain of the Anne Holly in attempting to transit St. Louis Harbor with a large tow, in darkness, under high current and flood conditions, and the failure of the management of American Milling, L.P., to provide adequate policy and direction to ensure the safe operation of its towboats. The National Transportation Safety Board also determined that the probable cause of the near breakaway of the President Casino on the Admiral was the failure of the owner, the local and State authorities, and the U.S. Coast Guard to adequately protect the permanently moored vessel from waterborne and current-related risks. A natural gas leak resulted when the natural gas supply line to the Admiral was severed in the course of the accident. When the line broke, natural gas began escaping. Although the escaping gas did not ignite, one of the first priorities in any situation during which natural gas is released should be to curtail the escape of product. An emergency repair team was summoned from the Laclede Gas Company to deal with the situation. The Laclede team could not shut off the natural gas from the regulator pit because, due to high water, the pit had filled with muddy water that prevented them from reaching the shutoff valves. The team was able to clamp off the ruptured natural gas hose, but by then, the leak had continued for about 3 hours. High water is not particularly unusual in this area; on the average, the river stage at St. Louis is 30 feet or higher more than 20 days a year. The river stage is 20 feet or higher nearly 70 days a year, on the average. Given this environment, the designers of this system should have considered that a facility set so close to the river might be difficult to access, depending on the river level. Laclede should have been aware of this design weakness and of the need to prepare its personnel to respond to emergencies affecting this regulator pit (and others on the waterfront) under all river conditions. But the Laclede response team had received no special preparation for responding to an emergency during high water and had to take a trial-and-error approach to shutting off the broken line. Therefore, the Safety Board concluded that Laclede Gas Company’s emergency responders had not been adequately prepared to stop the uncontrolled flow of natural gas resulting from this accident. Therefore, the National Transportation Safety Board makes the following safety recommendation to the Laclede Gas Company:#

Page 33 Require that your emergency response teams participate in port contingency plan drill exercises involving permanently moored vessels that are supplied with natural gas. (P-00-19) The Safety Board also issued safety recommendations to the U.S. Coast Guard, the Research and Special Programs Administration, the States of Missouri and Illinois, the cities of St. Louis and East St. Louis, the National League of Cities, the American Association of Port Authorities, the American Gas Association, the American Public Gas Association, President Casinos, Inc., and American Milling, L.P. In your response to the recommendation in this letter, please refer to Safety Recommendation P-00-19. If you need additional information, you may call (202) 314-6170. Chairman HALL and Members HAMMERSCHMIDT, GOGLIA, BLACK, and CARMODY concurred in this recommendation. By: Jim Hall Chairman#